The Overall Score: 'Silent Hill: Townfall' takes psychological horror in a new direction
By Marek Reynolds
Oct. 16 2026
Game developer Konami recently released their newest edition of “Silent Hill,” successfully maintaining their track record of releasing a new game every year. The last installment, “Silent Hill f,” focused on an action-oriented combat system and, more importantly, a new location: it did not take place in a Silent Hill. This lets newer companies give their own take on what “Silent Hill” really means. “Townfall” not only takes the series into a new location, but also expands beyond the characters players control, while keeping its core message intact.
Players play as Simon Ordell, who seems to have washed up in the fictional town of St. Amelia, Scotland, with a hospital bracelet on his wrist and an IV bag attached to his arm. As in previous takes of the games, Ordell is here to seek redemption for a past wrongdoing. Something is wrong in this small oceanside town: something horrible has happened. For sale signs are everywhere. Memorial signs, with posters and pictures of people, line the heart of the town, bearing the words “Whatever heart this town had has stopped beating.” In contrast, protest signs against the mysterious company CEG are clearly visible. The game delves deeply into Ordell's guilt, taking the series in a different and refreshing direction. While “Silent Hill 2” is widely regarded as one of the best psychological horror games, with an active story and remarkable attention to detail, later releases have not lived up to that standard. Fans of the series may go into “Townfall” expecting one outcome but end up surprised; its ending offers a refreshing way to explore the guilt and regret of these characters, and how Simon’s choices affected not only him, but the town itself. The game continues with two other characters and playable sections: Zoe, a nurse who handled home visits during the disaster that affected the town and has an odd past with Simon, and Richard, someone who seems to try to help Simon but also has demons he must deal with.
As usual with the series, psychological horror and visual metaphors are heavily at play, especially as the town transforms into an enemy design. Yet, what makes this game stand out from others in the series is that all the gameplay is first-person. This intensifies the claustrophobic feeling of the narrow Scottish town, and as areas shift, the setting can create moments of an uneasy, dreamlike state for the player. Like “Silent Hill 2,” a core mechanic is an enemy indicator radio. Still, “Townfall” uses a portal CRTV (portal TV), which fits the game's 1990s vibe while also offering a new way to track enemies, including letting players track nearby enemies' tunes and allowing Simon to see them with an almost X-ray vision. This even adds to Simon’s known psychological struggles and the eerier scene within St. Amelia. As for the town itself, Screen Burn Interactive's staff shows a love of Scotland and captures a very familiar vibe from real Scottish seaside towns.
One concern is that the game is not as scary as other installments. It is certainly more suspenseful, with moments when players must run from an enemy and hide in a closet until the cost becomes clear. The main stalker enemy, a large, armless monster with odd flesh balls growing from its back, is more aggressive, but that aggression mostly serves to build suspense. For example, when it corners a player, it forces them to wait for more than a minute until they can finally get out. While there is a difficulty setting to make the game easier or harder, there is also a puzzle difficulty setting, which may be necessary for players struggling with the puzzles. Many are very hard: some are almost completely unclear, and this is only on the normal puzzle difficulty. As for game difficulty, it gets hard when players enter combat encounters. Players have only four true options — melee, block, shoot, or run. Nothing new, and nothing very groundbreaking, which is not necessarily a bad thing. Players need to manage Simon’s health, melee durability, and ammo, which is typical of more modern games.
The game offers a fresh story for the beloved “Silent Hill” franchise and a solid 12-to-15 hour experience that fans of psychological horror will enjoy. While the gameplay is fun, with CRT-style graphics and the series’ first first-person game, it still follows fairly simple mechanics. Overall, fans of “Silent Hill” will find “Silent Hill: Townfall” enjoyable and worth their time.
Overall Score: 8/10
Photo by Rocco Fonseca